« HOW TO MAKE AN OUTLINE FOR A NOVEL-TO-BE | Main | DISCUSSING THE SECRET BETWEEN US »

CAN YOU KEEP A SECRET?

Naturally, I’m thinking about this because my new book. The Secret Between Us is on sale, contests are running, and I’m booking phone visits with reading groups to discuss it. Secrets – why we keep them, when we tell them, whether they help or hurt – are bound to be part of the discussion.

Want to help me prepare? Here are some questions.

Yes or no. Do you have a secret you’ve never told another living soul?

Yes or no. Did you ever keep a secret from a parent?

Yes or no. Have you kept a secret from a spouse?

Yes or no. Are there any situations when keeping a secret is the best thing to do?

I thought about these issues often while I was writing The Secret Between Us. Using the word ‘secret’ is something of a set-up. From the get-go, the reader knows that a secret if the focal point of the book.

If you’ve read my earlier blogs on this book, you’ll remember that its original title was Driving at Night. I loved the ambiguity of it, the juxtaposition of the physical act of driving at night, as occurs in the opening scene of the book, with the figurative act of feeling one’s way through the murky times in life. My publisher came up with The Secret Between Us, and from a marketing standpoint, it is better. There’s something about a secret that makes people lean in, cup an ear, and listen close.

What is it about secrets that makes them so appealing? Is it their hidden nature? Their potential for dirt or intimacy or even betrayal?

When you think about it, secrets are a staple of fiction. I’ve dealt with them in many of my books. Jenny, in Flirting With Pete, kept a major secret. The secret held by Gretchen, the title character in The Woman Next Door, kept the tension up through three neighborhood marriages and much of the book. And no less than four characters grapple with secrets in Family Tree.

One of my favorites when it comes to secrets is For My Daughters. This is the book I wrote after reading The Bridges of Madison County and seriously doubting that a woman could meet the love of her life during a summer fling and afterward return to her life with no one ever the wiser. My Virginia wasn't so lucky. Now, at the age of seventy and in failing health, she has a secret to tell her daughters. The reader learns that at the outset, and doesn’t learn the secret until the end of the book. It keeps her reading.

So. How about you? Right now, right here. Want to share your thoughts about secrets?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Comments

Everybody has secrets even if they say they don't!

Ok here are my answers to your questions-
have a secret that I've never told another soul? Yes

Kept a secret from a parent? Yes

Ever kept a secret from a spouse? Yes

Situations when keeping a secret is the best thing to do? Yes

Often I think that people may assume that you keep a secret out of shame, guilt,or fear of being judged by a decision. People assume that a secret involves lies and scandal, typically deceit. But a secret can simply be the truth about something that is only hidden for a while, until enough time has passed, given just the right circumstance it can be a valued gift of knowledge. Being a mother, the strongest motivating factor would be to protect one of my children from learning to much information at a time in their life that they are not prepared to fully understand. I am not suggesting lying to a child, I have been asked specific questions by one of my children. At the time I did not think that all the information would be helpful, so I asked her if she trusted me and she said yes, so I told her that I would tell her only what I thought she was ready to learn and then later when the time was right we could discuss more details. The only reason that the way I handled this worked out was because my child knows that I only have her best interest at heart, I would not suggest this for a relationship that has rocky past or issues with trust. I knew from a young age with this child that I would have some very important things to tell her and I've been very careful building a solid foundation, everything very deliberate so that one day the things that have been "secret" will be valued by her when she is ready.

If one does not reveal every detail of their life to others, it is not keeping a secret, it is more the sin of omission. I can answer yes to all your questions.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)